Thursday, May 13, 2021

Fact Check

McAuliffe overstates school progress in Petersburg, Va. during his governorship

Former and perhaps future Gov. Terry McAuliffe recently said that student performance in Peterburg, one of Virginia’s most financially troubled cities, vastly improved when...

“U.S. Census Bureau confirms huge conflict in total number of voters in 2020 election.”

Census worker Jennifer Pope wears a mask at a U.S. Census walk-up counting site in Greenville, Texas, on July 31, 2020. (AP)Source link

Low unemployment in Iowa after the pandemic

If Your Time is shortIowa will drop in June the federal portion of unemployment benefits related to COVID-19 that out-of-work residents had received. Republican Gov....

CO2 output from making an electric car battery isn’t equal to driving a gasoline car for 8 years

If Your Time is shortProduction of a lithium-ion battery for an electric vehicle emits carbon dioxide equivalent to operating a gasoline car for about...

Post Misleads on Japan’s Policy for Donating Blood After COVID-19 Vaccination

SciCheck Digest Japan only recently adopted guidelines for accepting blood donations from those who have received COVID-19 vaccines. The guidelines are intended to give donors...

No, the COVID-19 vaccines won’t make colds and flus extremely lethal

If Your Time is shortExperts say this claim is unfounded. COVID-19 vaccines help your body avoid illness while creating an immune response to the virus....

US Politics
Latest

Cheney: McCarthy ‘not leading with principle’

“For reasons that I don’t understand leaders in my party have decided to embrace the former president,” Cheney said. Cheney said she was gobsmacked...

Justices consider hearing a case on ‘most offensive word’

WASHINGTON (AP) — Robert Collier says that during the seven years he worked as an operating room aide at Parkland Memorial Hospital in Dallas,...

Candidate seeks recount in Virginia attorney general race

FALLS CHURCH, Va. (AP) — A Republican who narrowly lost the nomination for attorney general at a party convention in Virginia is requesting a...

The former Marine who holds Democrats’ Trumpiest district

The tattooed former Marine is willing to challenge party convention at a time when his single vote couldn’t be more valuable to Speaker Nancy...

Capitol siege, immigration issues mark congressional debate

SANTA FE, N.M. (AP) — Republican congressional candidate Mark Moores went on the attack against a Democratic opponent in a final pair of network...

LGBTQ

Laverne Cox will be the new host of E!’s iconic red carpet coverage / LGBTQ Nation

Laverne CoxPhoto: ShutterstockE! recently announced that actor Laverne Cox will be the new host of the network’s iconic red carpet coverage, Live From E! The...

Ellen DeGeneres is ending her talk show / LGBTQ Nation

Ellen on the phone with Michelle ObamaPhoto: Screenshot/InstagramEllen DeGeneres’s long-running daytime talk show will be coming to an end. “I became a comedian because I...

She grew up with MLK and was Kamala Harris’ gym buddy. Meet Donzaleigh Abernathy. / LGBTQ Nation

This is the first article in “We Dream On,” a three-part profile of actress, singer, and civil rights icon Donzaleigh Abernathy. Her parents were...

Tech

Microchip Tech: Fiscal Q4 Earnings Snapshot

CHANDLER, Ariz. (AP) _ Microchip Technology Inc. (MCHP) on Thursday reported fiscal fourth-quarter net income of $116 million.The Chandler, Arizona-based company said it had...

Nintendo profits boom as people stuck at home play games

TOKYO (AP) — Nintendo Co.’s profit for the fiscal year that ended in March jumped 86% on healthy sales of its Switch handheld machine...

Big-name scientists surprised to find themselves on journal board

Must read

McAuliffe overstates school progress in Petersburg, Va. during his governorship

Former and perhaps future Gov. Terry McAuliffe recently said that student performance in Peterburg, one of Virginia’s most financially troubled cities, vastly improved when...

Cheney: McCarthy ‘not leading with principle’

“For reasons that I don’t understand leaders in my party have decided to embrace the former president,” Cheney said. Cheney said she was gobsmacked...

Microchip Tech: Fiscal Q4 Earnings Snapshot

CHANDLER, Ariz. (AP) _ Microchip Technology Inc. (MCHP) on Thursday reported fiscal fourth-quarter net income of $116 million.The Chandler, Arizona-based company said it had...

Laverne Cox will be the new host of E!’s iconic red carpet coverage / LGBTQ Nation

Laverne CoxPhoto: ShutterstockE! recently announced that actor Laverne Cox will be the new host of the network’s iconic red carpet coverage, Live From E! The...

Feodora Chiosea/iStock

The journal Ecosystem Health and Sustainability (EHS) has an enviable roster of high-profile scientists on its editorial board, including noted biologist Paul Ehrlich, an emeritus professor at Stanford University, and Jerry Franklin, an ecosystem analyst at University of Washington, Seattle.

There’s only one problem: Many board members are no longer involved with EHS—if they ever were. “I can remember no contact with the journal for years, if ever,” Ehrlich says. “I should not be appearing as associated with the journal,” Franklin adds.

Their names ended up on the journal’s masthead, along with many others, when the Ecological Society of America (ESA) and the Ecological Society of China (ESC) jointly launched EHS 6 years ago. But that collaboration has ended, and several scientists contacted by Science were unaware EHS still bills them as “international advisors” or “subject editors.” Such padding can make a journal look more prestigious than it is—and help it qualify for an impact factor, crucial for attracting submissions.

EHS Editor-in-Chief Lu Yonglong, an ecologist at Xiamen University, says it is “really a surprise to me” that several scientists balk at being listed as editorial board members. He says the journal has regularly informed them of EHS’s status, providing a list of nine emails sent over the past 18 months to all those listed as advisers and editors. But Lu concedes the EHS website “may not be upgraded often” and says he will remove the names of scientists who ask him.

It’s not uncommon for so-called predatory journals to enlist scientists as board members without their knowledge. A study published last year found that of the almost 4000 scientists in Australia who are on the editorial boards of potentially predatory journals, about one-quarter are unaware of it. To expose such journals, one scientist signed up his dog, an American Staffordshire terrier named Ollie, as an editorial board member for six journals.

The practice appears to be far less common among more respectable journals like EHS, but is not unheard of. Johannes Knops of Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University in Suzhou, China, recently had his name removed as an “editorial member” from the journal Sciences in Cold and Arid Regions; he says he never agreed to the job. “I used to tell students to look at the reviewing editors to know the quality of a journal,” Knops says. But now, “You have to contact some editors to see if they’re real.” (The journal’s editors did not respond to an email from Science.)

Filling out a board with high-profile scientists can boost a journal’s odds of being included in Clarivate’s Science Citation Index Expanded, which is a step toward getting an impact factor. Doing so without their consent “borders on predatory,” says Xiaotian Chen, a professor of library science at Bradley University in Peoria, Illinois. But given what’s at stake, “fudges here are not a surprise,” says a publishing industry executive who asked not to be identified.

ESA and ESC agreed in 2013 to set up a new open-access journal to create an international publishing opportunity for ecologists from China; ESC paid ESA 1 million yuan ($150,000) per year to publish it. Prominent ESA members and past presidents joined the international advisory board to help recruit authors and develop affiliations with Chinese scientists, says former ESA President Ann Bartuska, a senior adviser at the nonprofit Resources for the Future.

The first issue appeared online in March 2015, but EHS struggled to attract submissions. “A problem the journal faced when starting up was that no Chinese authors would submit to a new journal without an impact factor, but other authors were reluctant to submit to a journal that seemed to target Chinese authors and readers,” says David Inouye, an ecologist at the Rocky Mountain Biological Laboratory who was ESA president in 2015. Academic publisher Taylor & Francis took over publication in fall 2017.

“I frankly assumed that when ESA severed ties, all of us were no longer on the board,” says Bartuska, who was surprised to find herself still listed. Seven scientists on the editorial board who responded to a query from Science gave similar responses. Former ESA President Norman Christensen was recently removed as co–editor-in-chief at his request, but agreed to be listed on the board of advisers.

The list is outdated in other ways. Most of the 79 subject editors’ names are linked to web pages or email addresses. But 35 of those links lead to “page not available” or similar messages.

EHS’s three associate editors, who are based in the United Kingdom, Italy, and the United States, all confirmed to Science that they actually for work for the journal. Lu “has been rigorous over his conduct of the journal,” says one of them, Geoff Squire of the James Hutton Institute in Dundee, U.K.

Today, EHS has a respectable impact factor of 2.315, and even scientists surprised to find themselves still on the editorial board are happy to see the journal surviving. “EHS has enriched the dialogue on sustainability,” says Jerry Melillo, of the Marine Biological Laboratory in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. The journal’s challenge now, says Associate Editor Hanqin Tian, of Auburn University in Alabama, “is to recruit more manuscripts from outside of China and maintain an international editorial board.”

Source link

- Advertisement -

More articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest article

McAuliffe overstates school progress in Petersburg, Va. during his governorship

Former and perhaps future Gov. Terry McAuliffe recently said that student performance in Peterburg, one of Virginia’s most financially troubled cities, vastly improved when...

Cheney: McCarthy ‘not leading with principle’

“For reasons that I don’t understand leaders in my party have decided to embrace the former president,” Cheney said. Cheney said she was gobsmacked...

Microchip Tech: Fiscal Q4 Earnings Snapshot

CHANDLER, Ariz. (AP) _ Microchip Technology Inc. (MCHP) on Thursday reported fiscal fourth-quarter net income of $116 million.The Chandler, Arizona-based company said it had...

Laverne Cox will be the new host of E!’s iconic red carpet coverage / LGBTQ Nation

Laverne CoxPhoto: ShutterstockE! recently announced that actor Laverne Cox will be the new host of the network’s iconic red carpet coverage, Live From E! The...

Justices consider hearing a case on ‘most offensive word’

WASHINGTON (AP) — Robert Collier says that during the seven years he worked as an operating room aide at Parkland Memorial Hospital in Dallas,...